Asymmetric denial of service In ruby-rack
Description
Rack has an unsafe default in Rack::QueryParser allows params_limit bypass via semicolon-separated parameters
Summary
Rack::QueryParser in version < 2.2.18 enforces its params_limit only for parameters separated by &, while still splitting on both & and ;. As a result, attackers could use ; separators to bypass the parameter count limit and submit more parameters than intended.
Details
The issue arises because Rack::QueryParser#check_query_string counts only & characters when determining the number of parameters, but the default separator regex DEFAULT_SEP = /[&;] */n splits on both & and ;. This mismatch means that queries using ; separators were not included in the parameter count, allowing params_limit to be bypassed.
Other safeguards (bytesize_limit and key_space_limit) still applied, but did not prevent this particular bypass.
Impact
Applications or middleware that directly invoke Rack::QueryParser with its default configuration (no explicit delimiter) could be exposed to increased CPU and memory consumption. This can be abused as a limited denial-of-service vector.
Rack::Request, the primary entry point for typical Rack applications, uses QueryParser in a safe way and does not appear vulnerable by default. As such, the severity is considered low, with the impact limited to edge cases where QueryParser is used directly.
Mitigation
Upgrade to a patched version of Rack where both & and ; are counted consistently toward params_limit.
If upgrading is not immediately possible, configure QueryParser with an explicit delimiter (e.g., &) to avoid the mismatch.
As a general precaution, enforce query string and request size limits at the web server or proxy layer (e.g., Nginx, Apache, or a CDN) to mitigate excessive parsing overhead.
Update Impact
Minimal update. May introduce new vulnerabilities or breaking changes.
Ecosystem | Package | Affected version | Patched versions |
|---|---|---|---|
debian 14 | 3.0.8-2 | ||
debian 12 | 2.2.20-0+deb12u1 | ||
debian 11 | 2.1.4-3+deb11u4 | ||
debian 13 | 3.0.8-2 | ||
rubygems | 2.2.18 | ||
rpm rhel10 | 0:0.12.1-1.el10_1.1 | ||
rpm rhel8 | 0:0.10.18-2.el8_10.7 | ||
rpm rhel8.4 | 0:0.10.8-1.el8_4.8 | ||
rpm rhel9 | 0:0.11.10-1.el9_7.1 | ||
rpm rhel9.4 | 0:0.11.7-2.el9_4.5 |
Aliases
References