Asymmetric denial of service - ReDoS In twisted
Description
Twisted: IMAP wildcardToRegexp() ReDoS
Summary
wildcardToRegexp() in twisted/mail/imap4.py converts IMAP LIST/LSUB wildcard patterns to Python regular expressions. It substitutes the two IMAP wildcards (* → (?:.*?) and % → (?:(?:[^\\/])*?)) but passes every other character through unchanged to re.compile(). This means that an authenticated IMAP client can send a quoted pattern string containing arbitrary regex syntax - including catastrophic-backtracking constructs such as (a+)+z.
Because Twisted runs a cooperative, single-threaded reactor, a blocking regex match freezes all I/O on the server for the duration of the match.
Vulnerable Code
twisted/mail/imap4.py
# line 4595 def wildcardToRegexp(wildcard, delim=None): wildcard = wildcard.replace("*", "(?:.*?)") if delim is None: wildcard = wildcard.replace("%", "(?:.*?)") else: wildcard = wildcard.replace("%", "(?:(?:[^%s])*?)" % re.escape(delim)) return re.compile(wildcard, re.I) # ← user input compiled verbatim...
# line 4993 class MemoryAccountWithoutNamespaces: def listMailboxes(self, ref, wildcard): ref = self._inferiorNames(_parseMbox(ref.upper())) wildcard = wildcardToRegexp(wildcard, "/") # ← user-supplied wildcard return [(i, self.mailboxes[i]) for i in ref if wildcard.match(i)]
Proof of Concept
from twisted.mail.imap4 import wildcardToRegexp import time rx = wildcardToRegexp("(a+)+z", "/") for n in [20, 22, 24, 26, 28]: victim = "a" * n t0 = time.perf_counter() rx.match(victim)...
Output on Twisted 25.5.0:
[*] Compiled regex: '(a+)+z' [*] Note: metacharacters ( ) + ? are NOT escaped - they go straight to re.compile() n time --- ---------- 20 0.153s 22 0.651s 24 2.941s...
Timing doubles roughly every two characters (exponential growth), confirming catastrophic backtracking.
Impact
Twisted's reactor is single-threaded and cooperative. A blocking re.match() call suspends the entire event loop - no other connection can be accepted, read, or written while the match runs. A single authenticated LIST command with a 28-character target mailbox name can stall the server for ~55 seconds.
An attacker who can register an account (or obtain credentials through other means) can:
CREATE a mailbox whose name is an exponential-blowup trigger string.
Issue LIST "" "(a+)+z" (or equivalent ReDoS pattern).
Repeat at ~1-minute intervals to keep the server permanently unavailable.
No exploit code or special privileges beyond an IMAP login are required.
Fix
Escape non-wildcard characters before compiling:
def wildcardToRegexp(wildcard, delim=None): # Split on the two IMAP wildcards, escape everything else parts = re.split(r'([*%])', wildcard) result = [] for p in parts: if p == '*': result.append('(?:.*?)') elif p == '%':...
Alternatively, apply re.escape() to the entire wildcard first, then substitute the (now-escaped) \* and \% tokens back with their regex equivalents.
Mitigation
Update Impact
Minimal update. May introduce new vulnerabilities or breaking changes.
Aliases
References