Description

SpiceDB: LookupResources with Multiple Entrypoints across Different Definitions Can Return Incomplete Results

Impact

If your schema includes the following characteristics:

You have a permission defined in terms of a union (+)

That union references the same relation on both sides, but one side arrows to a different permission

Then you might have missing LookupResources results when checking the permission. This only affects LookupResources; other APIs calculate permissionship correctly.

A small concrete example:

relation doer_of_things: user | group#member
permission do_the_thing = doer_of_things + doer_of_things->admin

A CheckPermission on do_the_thing will return the correct permissionship, but a LookupResources on do_the_thing may miss resources.

A Comprehensive Example

If you have a schema with a structure like this:

definition special_user {}

definition user {
  relation special_user_mapping: special_user
  permission special_user = special_user_mapping
}
definition group {
   relation member: user...
Show more

And these relationships:

system:somesystem#viewer@group:somegroup#membership
group:somegroup#member@user:someuser1
user:someuser1#special_user_mapping@special_user:specialuser

And you call LookupResources with:

subject_type: user
subject_id: someuser1
permission: view
resource_type: system

You would expect to receive system:somesystem in the results, but you do not.

Note that this only applies to LookupResources; if you CheckPermission for that resource specifically, it will return HasPermission.

Patches

The issue is fixed in v1.47.1. Upgrading to this version will remediate this issue.

Workarounds

N/A

References

N/A

Mitigation

Aliases

References